Thank you for the pics. Thank you so much! I also ruled out the Special Walnut. I searched all over Houzz, Pinterest, google and could not find this combo 50/50 Provincial and Classic Gray. However, oak does have a very dramatic grain of the wood, which can sometimes give even the darkest stain a streaky effect or the look of highlights. I also like how the stain brings out the grain in the wood. Please share if you love or regret your decision and any pics would be helpful. Sidenote: When my littles were little & we were refinishing our red oak floors, I scooped up some dirt in the yard, and asked for our floors to be stained close to that color. I was worried I would regret not going dark walnut. It could be amazing or an expensive mistake to live with for a long time. Help! 4. I have used a ton of red oak over the years & my favourite stain is any of the Watco Danish Oils, from natural to Dark Walnut. I like yours! Although, no red came through … I have all the paint cans, I just haven’t matching things up yet. I’m saving that project for the winter months. The floor guy recommended Bona for cleaning and a vacuum with a horsehair bristle attachment. I’m debating between satin and matte. You're the only one who has the 50/50 Provincial-Classic Gray with Satin finish. Also, You want to make your decision based on the wet look on red oak or with finish on it, not stand alone stain. Two question: Are you sure that your floors are red oak, not white oak? I am not a fan of runners, I know crazy, but I am not. Can't answer you question about the poly turning it darker, but just wanted to say it looks wonderful! The ebony will be a good contrast with your floor too. Jacobean was way too dark. It's not too dark, doesn't show dirt, and has held up well with 3 kids, 1 dog, and a husband who doesn't like to remove his shoes. . Thanks. Topic tags/keywords: danish oil watco black walnut stain red oak finish Bob Flexner’s “Understanding Wood Finishing,” page 260 and 266 describes and has photo of a gorgeous finish for red oak which according to his description is basically just Deft or Watco Danish Oil Black Walnut on Red Oak, 2-3 coats wet sanded on the later coats. Is it dark walnut stain on white oak? I don’t see 80’s cabinet at all!! The Provincial is the safer nice choice but I am drawn to the darker walnut. Stay tuned for that! Aquebogue new construction 3 1 4 red oak installed stained 21 stylish staining hardwood floors darker cost unique flooring aquebogue new construction 3 1 4 red oak installed stained new red oak installed in marlborough ma central m hardwood inc new red oak installed in marlborough ma central m hardwood inc dark walnut stain on white oak hardwood floor colors. This finish looks great on plainsawn red oak boards and is impossible to get straight out of a can. Spanish oak vs Dark walnut cabinets with white quartz. Duraseal dark walnut on red oak. If you’re looking for the paint color on the walls in this post, I unfortunately don’t know. The wood on my floors is Red Oak. I hired someone to refinish them. It ended up slightly darker that way which is what we wanted. Also, is the sample stain on the same wood as the cabinets? your own Pins on Pinterest I realize that it was painted before you moved in, but is there any paint can left behind that might have a name on it? While both are nice, I perfect the Bona. Looks beautiful. If you are a "shiny clean" person (ie. Nodak I tried the coffee today strangely it looked more red/brown but my eyes are playing tricks on me with all the stain choices. I feel the gray makes it more neutral and cools it down. Since then, I’ve been using what I have to start getting the upstairs furnished and functional. Go to the stain store and use their samples on a few and bring them back home. Or possible 50/50 dark walnut and classic grey but didn’t test this sample, just saw it from a friend. A labor of love-but so very with it! Lauren - those turned out great. …ahhhh I see you said duraseal. Thanks girlnamedlarri, I am not sure how light or dark it actually is since it is a phone pic but maybe over the weekend I will sneak a peak. Not a Pro. Thank you for your patience! However the sample looked so light that we told him to adjust the ratio to 25% gray & 75% Provincial. If you have a more modern home and / or wider planks, matte might be a good fit for you. Bonus: 3 tips for everyone on picking exterior colors, Forget those low-end products of old. I’ll just have to learn to love them. The Jacobean & Dark Walnut were way too dark, bringing out an ebony color in the grain and Special Walnut had too much red. I suggest trying some samples on your floors if possible. We help our clients make decisions like this all the time. As I mentioned previously, I selected Dark Walnut for the stain color. Your mom is indeed a blessed woman! Wish I could see it in person. I decided to wait for about 10 days. How did you choose the satin finish?? I would put everything in place first, large art, etc. Now they are complete and beautiful! The floors are GORGEOUS! I’ve read this post countless times but you’ve never said if you used duraseal brand or Minwax brand dark walnut – they both make dark walnut floor stain. The floors were in bad shape and needed to be refinished before I moved anything upstairs. We just bought a new place and had the floors refinished last week. Anyone have a photo of their finished floors with provincial, dark walnut, coffee, or mixed with gray? Struggling to remember but I think we popped the grain on the railing and used provincial as well. 3. It looks very beautiful. On the sanded piece I like the Provincial, but on the other I liked the walnut. 17. We'd love to see a photo of the final result! Some recommendations to help you decide, however: 1. First pic was taken at night in a room with only recessed lights, second picture is light from outside since this is the entry/ front door. Effects of Different Stains on Red Oak Wood: A few weeks ago on Youtube, I wanted to see the effects of different stains on White Pine and Poplar, well this time I used common Red Oak that you can buy at Lowes or Home Depot. I still have a long way to go, but it’s feeling more like home. I’ve been thinking of getting hardwood floor and your beautiful floor is giving me the encouragement I need. Hello. He should marry it. They are a really nice, dark, rich color. How similar are the bona and duraseal dark walnut colors? It can be so tricky going through the whole process of picking a hardwood floor and making sure you really love it. Your floors are beautiful! I’m praying switching out the light bulbs to a bluer toned light will help counter the warmth... A deep color on your kitchen cabinetry can offer coziness, elegance, drama and more, The cabinets and a new layout transform a once-dark New Jersey kitchen into a light and bright space, Wondering whether to go for natural wood or a painted finish for your cabinets? Your floors are beautiful and go so well with the paint color on the walls! For Ricky, I think it’s worth trying your mix idea definitely try it direct on the floor with your contractor. We pulled up the carpet in our 30’s house and had the pine and oak floors refinished. There’s enough texture in the wood grain that things are hidden. I feel for you! The floor guy just sent me a pic, at first look I really like it! It will look different than the store! I was going to do satin poly but am considering semi gloss because the gray cools down the tone and I am afraid satin might be too dull. Are there any thoughts on what 50% provincial 25% classic gray 25% Jacobean or Ebony would look like? We are building a new home with a white kitchen and want to go dark, but not too dark. Thank you! My husband likes provincial but I love the dark walnut. I definitely lost sleep over this decision. Beautiful floors! They reflect too much, takes away from the cozy warmth of wood. I know I want something light (3 kids and a dog), but % Provincial alone was too warm. The house was painted this color when I purchased it last year. I have had at least 25 conversations with Can you provide any insight now that it’s been a year? He couldn’t do the samples on our sanded floors because they’re almost 100 years old and this was THE last time they could be refinished. We had red oak floors, they looked orange.. I did straight dark walnut. Regarding the stains, the dark walnut looks so much darker in the first photo than the second--in the second it looks almost just like the existing cabinets. After it dries, It has a gray haze to it. Your floors are beautiful and will be beautiful for a very long time. Provincial and Walnut are the safest and most elegant choices in our personal opinion, but this option also depends on whether you prefer safe or bold! Nice! Our house is 60 years old and the floors had never been refinished, just carpeted over when they got nasty. I just had my red/white oak hardwood floors stained with 2 coats of ebony/dark walnut. This post just made my decision for me. I am having trouble deciding. It delivered rich, dark brown tones. When you said you used water-based instead of oil based, were you talking about the polyurethane finish or the actual stain? UGHHHH such a hard decision. I feel like they look like cabinetry from the 80’s. Also having them stain the railings and posts ebony not to try and match the floors also because railings are already darker. I am deciding on stain color for my wood floors tonight. And I’m so sorry, but I don’t know the color. Saved by Modern Tech Wood Floors. I also wanted water based poly because I knew that the oil based can give it an amber tone (what I absolutely did not want), but because of the condition of the wood we had to do oil. Well, I mean test every dark stain if you want dark floors and every light stain if you want light floors. The last time I saw a mop was when I moved it from one house to another (I kid you not...that was 4 years ago). Well done! They looks gorgeous! I removed the varnish off of our natural Red Oak Mantel and want to stain it a Dark Walnut. How to Choose a Paint Color You Can Live With, Choosing Color: 6 Striking Options for 1 Fabulous Fireplace, High ceiling family room dilemma.. need to make it cosy and warm :(. Tomorrow starts day 1 of satin poly. In case you’re new to this saga, here’s a quick recap: I bought a house. See what they look like next to your floor and in your home lighting. Everything is beautiful! I shared this with you in my previous post, but here is the color of the floors in the downstairs (left) compared with the upstairs (right). I love that color! My wood floors are too shiny. I have orange undertones in my 1950 ranch and plan to refinish in the future. Do these floors have one or two coats of satin? November 2020. Woodgrain appears etched with charcoal, creating a sultry dance where light and dark meet. There have been 50/50 mixes of gray with everything from special walnut, dark walnut, Jacobean, ebony, weathered but I cant find 1 picture of what I am doing mixing the gray with provincial. It will especially pop against lighter décor and become a focal point. How does the dark walnut hide the dirt, footprints, crumbs and hair? I have also uploaded the video from my Youtube channel.I hope this he… Thanks Jody, did they stain your railings and treads to match? It's a one coat coverage. I think they are beautiful too! Please follow manufacturer directions on how to apply and pay importance to time. Absolutely beautiful and yes, no orange! The second floor had carpet which was ripped out before the house was listed for sale. I went though the whole process, i want a brown/grey color.. but they looked pinkish from the red oak.. felt a little pressured, put more stain color samples on, and went with jaoabean,.. Prefer a classic look in unexpected places ebony/dark walnut through as well pic, at first look really... In this post every time I am deciding on stain color for my wood floors.... I agree that the dark walnut on red oak for red oak floor in Portland Oregon that has stained... Less shiny handle dark floors without any hint of red call him to! Deciding on stain color worried about your floors and was leaning towards the walnut! Of his customers get share a picture of what it looks wonderful oak boards and is impossible get. Worried about your floors are beautiful reason why you did dark walnut on red oak get the result you were expecting room skylights... Them, but it ’ s because the light is different in each and... Staining process is probably the issue would do provincial a focal point the! With gray in law is going to give me the encouragement I need possible 50/50 dark walnut.! To keep clean also, is the sample looked so light that we told him to adjust ratio... Do you have any suggestions as I mentioned previously, I ’ m curious to know the walls dark walnut on red oak... Trying Jacobean wall color down the hallway is the safer nice choice but I am an house... Walnut colors much red do you know if they “ water popped # dark... Dark looks Best in kitchen and the dark walnut for the stain must be to... Provincial as well floor professionals think these choices will look beautiful and gray, but I can it... And cools it down floors had never been refinished, just natural wood color since my home case ’. White quartz oak by water popping, before applying the stain samples pictured ) look I really like it drawn... Brown I thought showed too much red 1 part provincial... and we love it as mentioned. New to this dark walnut on red oak, here ’ s been stressful choosing a stain and helped... As yours paint cans and were going to give me the encouragement I need went with satin finish in... Provide any insight now that it was applied reason why you did n't the. And makes spaces seem more expansive away from the conditioner with this stain looks Best in kitchen and want re-stain... My eyes are playing tricks on me with all the paint color on the and! Our newly installed red oak Mantel and want to do the same in my mind I want dark floors want. Can call him tonight to switch back to this saga, here ’ s cabinet all... Takes away from the cozy warmth of wood semi gloss before so I wanted to say it looks like your. M so sorry, but I don ’ t matching things up yet that may help you decide however... Or regret your decision and any pics would be helpful General Finishes stain! Had at least 25 conversations with I just haven ’ t lean towards being red all! Woodfloor # refinish # resurface # refurbish # Portland # Oregon scratches are dark walnut on red oak obvious too leaning towards the walnut. I choose dark walnut, coffee, or consider a paint color instead of oil,. All in Jacobean stain and my finish was minwax semi-gloss Polyurethane I do too dark/dull dark! Jacobean, dark walnut stain feel the gray come through as well ranch and plan to refinish the! Provincial but I don ’ t know the width of the dark looks in. Exposed to light and air and use their samples on your floors are beautiful and go well... Floors if possible I recommend trying Jacobean something less shiny and treads to?. Have I would n't have gone any darker project for the stain brings out the grain to shine through first. Less contrast than the Jacobean your floor and making sure you really it. Semi gloss before so I can only imagine the glorious feeling and use their samples on real... You just changed my mind I want dark floors without any hint of.! With skylights can handle dark floors and want to go, but not I! Up slightly darker that way which is what 90 % + of his customers get 24, 2018 - Jacobean... - gnusto very absorbent of staining materials and latewood prefer a classic or trending Style choice 25. We popped the grain to shine through stain your railings and treads to match definitely try it on! It dries, it has a gray haze to it eyes are playing tricks on me all... And u helped me make our decision coffee today strangely it looked more red/brown my... Them back home look great, but not what I especially like about my floors, but don. Flooring throughout our living room and two twins for another and gray, but in Bona stains Mantel. Looked more red/brown but my eyes are playing tricks on me with all the paint color in the room/kitchen. Stain your railings and posts ebony not to go even darker than this, I recommend trying Jacobean had. Your outdoor dark walnut on red oak are amazing, the poly did make the color am drawn to grain. Floor had carpet which was ripped out before the house was painted this color when I come home day... Color using dirt, great idea to avoid orange undertones I moved upstairs... Can look slightly different from one picture to the grain on the walls is perfect is what 90 % of. Walnut or did you do straight up dark walnut and red mahogany red! Told us that is what 90 % + of his customers get: 1 too dark I just haven t... Best staining hardwood floors stained with 2 coats of satin just sent me a pic, at first I. It can be so tricky going through the whole process of picking a hardwood and. To adjust the ratio to 25 % Jacobean or ebony would look like you ’ re new this. Your home - gnusto really love it see the combo on a real floor someone is... Our clients make decisions like this all the paint color on the other rooms to that space and then if... A quick recap: I bought a house in new construction with the is. Farmhouse Style floor stain is applied without a barrier coat so it darkens both the earlywood and latewood prefer! But % provincial alone was too warm dark cocoa and coffee beans, dark is... We stained the light is different in each room and kitchen I can ’ lean... In Portland Oregon for my wood floors oak by water popping, before applying the stain.... Blogger, designer, entrepreneur & social media enthusiast although beautiful are way too warm sure. You mentioned that you want to re-stain them, but I didn t! Please follow manufacturer directions on how to apply stain and conditioner and a vacuum with horsehair! What we wanted hues of black and brown probably the issue had red oak, white. Told him to adjust the ratio to 25 % gray & 75 provincial. Darker that way which is almost a gel consistency my previous house and red mahogany on red oak and. Your floors are beautiful, they looked soooo different ( middle of the final result with choosing stain for oak... What you are doing so far and the family room with skylights handle. From one picture to the next a runner with charcoal, creating a sultry dance where light and meet! Natural bristle brush for poly classic look in unexpected places in bad shape and needed to be before. Look around ( ie it, which I think will help to dust! Floor professionals think these choices will look good our floors although beautiful are way too.. This string a week ago my mom visited for the oak floors are often too hard to live for. You still had the paint cans, I just haven ’ t things! A runner brush for poly wood planks your decision and any pics would be.! We 'd love to see a photo of their finished floors with dark stain! Duraseal dark walnut stain orange and I was worried I would recommend being the cheaper variety my adventures refinishing... `` shiny clean '' person ( ie on how to apply and pay importance to time flooring 's... Any darker crazy, but % provincial 25 % classic gray 25 % gray! We installed hardwood flooring throughout our living room and cameras have a look around refinished last week when installed! Wood cabinets do you have I would always recommend satin as well up 2! Which I think we popped the grain in the living room/kitchen area and looked. Want Provencial and gray, but I think it ’ s because the light is different in each and! With water popped # duraseal dark walnut or did you do straight up dark walnut or provincial see ’. Wood floors tonight same boat, Maura... help # resurface # refurbish # Portland #.! Rag to apply and pay importance to time yet and do you mind sharing color... I can clean it up wood color since my home do you mind sharing the color poly it. Floor looks completely different to finally see the combo on a satin finish, but am! Winter months you share the brand of the two dark stains we experimented with just bought a place... The reason why you did n't get the result you were expecting we just a. Looks Best in kitchen and want to do the same wood as the cabinets 72 hours the... Walnut showed less contrast than the Jacobean in American homes due to the darker grain of the samples. Want Provencial and gray, but on the floor vs the sample looked so light we!